Go
to Main
Occasional
Papers: Vol:2 September 1999 No.1
Foreword
- Dr. Salehuddin
Ahmed, Managing Director
Foreword
Microcredit
is now regarded as a powerful and effective tool to alleviate
poverty. Bangladesh is the pioneer in this field and it has
become a global movement now. The potentials of microcredit
is enormous, but there are challenges ahead as well. PKSF
as the apex body of microcredit financing in Bangladesh is
deeply involved in operational aspects. Side by side, PKSF
is trying to develop some standards of microcredit operations.
There are some unresolved issues which PKSF would like to
resolve to face the future challenges. To document the experiences
of PKSF and its position on various issues, PKSF has brought
out one issue of "Microcredit Review" which got
appreciation from a wide range of people. This is the second
issue of "Microcredit Review" which contains articles
written by PKSF staff members who are basically involved in
microcredit operations. These articles are not really written
within a rigorous academic and analytical framework. The articles
have adopted a problem solving approach. We hope that these
articles will provide some guidelines to strengthen the microcredit
operations in Bangladesh and elsewhere around the world.
- Dr. Salehuddin Ahmed, Managing Director
Flood Preparedness: The Case
for Creation of a disaster Management Fund
-
Mosharraf Hossain Khan
The centurys
worst devastating flood of 1998 has caused havoc and destruction
in all spheres of our economic and social life. The scar of
the flood has left before all of us in general, and the Government
in particular, a gigantic task of recovery. The flood has
taught us many important lessons as also exposed our weaknesses
in preparedness and capabilities in facing calamities of such
catastrophic dimension.
The nation
became united once again to fight a war against the deluge.
People from all walks of life irrespective of their cast and
creed, age and status and their political affiliation, came
with helping hand to provide succour to the flood affected
people languishing in the relief camps. Although the countrys
more than two-thirds area was affected with flood forcing
millions of people to take refuge in relief camps and temporary
make-shifts on high lands, roads and highways, our relief
operations mostly remained limited in and around Dhaka city.
This was less because large number of needy and relief seeking
people from over-populated capital slums and suburbs thronged
to the relief camps of the capital city but more because of
our incapability to reach the remote and inaccessible places
with aid and relief. At one stage of the peak of the flood,
the rest of the country appeared to be in threat of being
cut off with the capital. The communications between villages
and thana head quarters with district head quarters in most
affected places were snapped leaving millions of affected
people unattended and in untold ordeals for months together.
The Governments efforts to reach aid to these inaccessible
places through its own administrative conduit were handicapped
due to lack of resources at the beginning. The local and international
voluntary organizations preferred to channel relief in their
own way and, surprisingly, some of the international donors
also preferred to channel their aid through the NGOs by-passing
the Governments channel. In a nutshell, there appeared
to be a stark lack of coordination every where.
Everybody
came up with providing relief to the affected people but there
was nobody to dictate priority and necessity. As a result,
the relief camps having risk-free easy access had plenty of
relief goods, those outside easy reach received scanty of
supplies while the remotest ones remained largely unattended.
In the process, we forgot one set of affected people, the
lower middle class people, who did not come to the relief
camps or did not force ahead in front to have relief. They
did not come partly because of middle class aristocracy
standing on their way to beg for help. The humanity demanded
that we searched out these marooned families and stood by
them to extend possible help. Only a coordinated approach
could ensure this.
While we
would deploy our all out efforts to fight out a decent and
dignified recovery from this devastation wrought by the flood,
we should also have time to think on our preparedness for
facing natural disaster of this nature in future given that
our country is prone to such calamities. Our future plan of
actions should be based on learning from the past. We have
talked of necessity of coordination and prioritization at
the time of emergency relief operations. The coordination
between the NGOs and the Government machinery would ensure
proper and judicious use of our scarce resources. While the
GO-NGO coordination in all spheres of development is in the
offing through the GNCC, an intimate look into the roles and
potentials of the NGOs at the time of such disaster may be
worth looking into. The potentials of these NGOs are rooted
in their following pro-people working features :
-
They
have been established with welfare motive to work for
and with the people.
-
They
enjoy more operational flexibility in comparison to
the Government establishments.
-
They
have clearly spelt out and enforceable accountability
and incentive provision for their staff- which is the
driving force of their commitment to work for the community.
-
The sponsors/executives
of the NGOs and most of the employees are permanent
inhabitants of their localities and as such are easily
accessible and close to the people.
-
Due to
their being locally based, they are available to their
members in times of need and exigencies almost round
the clock.
-
They
have an integrated approach towards community development.
-
Their
flexibility in approach and work has attracted confidence
of the donors.
There
are thousands of such NGOs working in far flung areas of the
country. These include the national level giants like BRAC,
Proshika, Gana Shasthya Kendra, Association for Social Advancement
(ASA) and a few others with Head Office at Dhaka. We have
seen the commendable activities and selfless performance of
these large NGOs in providing relief and other support to
the affected people. But what about thousands of other local
NGOs ? The vast potentials of this large number of local institutions
remained mostly unused during the time of our great need due
to lack of direction and resources. These NGOs could have
stood by the side of their marooned members had they had a
program and preparedness for this. But the contrary happened
in reality. The NGOs were thrown out of work due to inundation
of their program areas and activities. Some of the NGOs even
could not pay usual salaries to their low paid employees due
to lack of income and work. Here, the cause for re-orientation
in program focus of the local NGOs to meet similar exigencies
in future and the case for creation of a Disaster Management
Fund comes in. These NGOs could be used as a local unit force
to fight the calamities at initial stages till the re-enforcement
arrives, provided this unit may be armed with appropriate
resources and logistics to fight such calamities in future.
Almost all these NGOs various development interventions
are funded by some or other donors. These donors also provided
help for flood victims but through other conduits easy to
reach. Given that Bangladesh is prone to perennial flood and
other natural calamities, it is worth-thinking that the NGOs
create a local Disaster Management Fund of their own so that
they do not have to play the role of a helpless silent on-lookers
at the time of distress and dire need of their members. The
proposed Fund could be created from the contribution of the
NGOs, the members and the donors. One may raise here the question
of accountability and transparency of the NGOs. A legal and
regulatory framework for these NGOs is in the offing at the
instance of the Government. The proposed framework is expected
to take care of the transparency and accountability issues.
Meanwhile the NGOs enrolled with the Palli Karma-Sahayak Foundation
(PKSF) may take lead in this respect.
PKSF was
established by the Government with a view to on-lending funds
to various agencies engaged in poverty alleviation. In addition
to lending fund to its client NGOs {termed as Partner Organizations
(POs)}, the PKSF is also trying to set norms and standards
for microcredit management. In addition to above, PKSF also
helps in capacity building of small and potential NGOs engaged
in microcredit through providing training and other logistic
supports. Till date, PKSF has brought about 172 POs with membership
enrollment of about 1.5 million under its fold. These POs
have programs spread over far flung areas of the country covering
almost all districts starting from Panchagar to Coxs
Bazar. The POs of PKSF are under strict supervision and monitoring
and as such have to follow a standardized accounting and book
keeping practice. The financial leverage available with PKSF
being only source of loanable fund for POs- helps it
to enforce compliance with rules and audit/accounting standards.
So, the question of accountability and transparency may be
considered resolved in case of the PKSF enrolled POs. The
donors may consider putting such fund in a central account
with PKSF for onward distribution to its POs against a Memorandum
of Understanding spelling out the management, monitoring and
reporting procedures for such fund. The proposed fund could
comprise of the following :
- Grant from the donors;
- Contribution from PKSF;
- Contribution from surplus
of earnings of the POs;
- Nominal contributions (Tk.
1 or 2 per week) from the members;
- Voluntary contribution from
any other agencies.
The
fund would be used by the POs for providing emergency relief
aid to the members to face the initial brunt of disaster like
flood, tidal bore, cyclone and tornado etc. and also to provide
interest free loans for housing, sanitation, tube-wells etc.
Under a pre-set guideline circulated by PKSF the role of PKSF
would be to :
- Sign Memorandum of Understanding
(MOU) with the donors to receive and manage the fund as
per guidelines to be prepared and issued in line with
the MOU.
- Open and maintain a central
Disaster Management Fund Account.
- Receive fund from the donors
and retail among POs based on their capabilities, coverage
and vulnerability of the working areas.
- Make yearly contributions
in the central account from own revenue.
- Cause POs to open local
Disaster Management Fund Account and manage it as per
guidelines.
- Cause POs to contribute
a fixed percentage of their earnings in the fund on yearly
basis.
- Ensure nominal contribution
from the members on weekly basis.
- Ensure that the proceeds
of the fund is not diverted to uses other than specified
in the guideline.
- Cause the POs to abide by
the book keeping and reporting requirements as per guidelines.
The
proposed fund once established would serve as a permanent
resource for disaster preparedness and relief operation at
local level. The fund would get triggered and activated automatically
on the onset of calamities. The PKSFs normal monitoring,
audit and inspection would apply equally to these funds. The
donors would have access to these accounts and would be entitled
to receive periodical reports from PKSF on the status of the
fund.
Establishment
of local Disaster Management Fund along the broad outline
enumerated above would not only meet the immediate need of
the affected people, but would also help us help ourselves
without waiting for the Government machinery to come to rescue
in times of such disasters in future. This would also ensure
more effective, judicious and transparent use of the donors
fund exactly where and when it is needed to face the disaster.
Above all, a Disaster Management Fund of this kind is now
considered a sine qua non to rehabilitate the
affected people in their own place so as to enable them to
start their income earning activities using microcredit provided
by the NGOs. In that sense, the proposed fund would also help
rehabilitation of the disaster affected microcredit
program of about more than one thousand agencies which is
otherwise in a threat of collapse.
Overlapping
- a Crucial Issue of Microcredit
- Md. Jashim
Uddin
Introduction
:
The practitioners
of microcredit are worried about credit overlapping. Overlapping
problem arises when more than one organization runs its microcredit
program in a particular area and a single person takes loans
from more than one organization simultaneously. Overlapping
problem may occur both at borrower and group levels, that
means, a person can take loan from more than one organization
or a group can take loan from different sources. It is difficult
for a particular organization to monitor or supervise its
credit program when a loanee takes loan from different sources.
Causes
of Overlapping :
(a) At loan receivers level :
- In general, inadequate supply
of loan compared with demand.
- Loan providing organizations
cannot provide sufficient amount of loan needed for a
particular project.
- Loan providing organizations
cannot meet the demand for seasonal loans.
- Delayed release of loan
from Microfinance Institutions (MFIs). A person may have
immediate demand for a loan for a particular time period.
If the loan providing organization cannot provide loan
within that time period, then the person is compelled
to take loan from another organization.
- Sometimes a borrower takes
loan for IGAs from one organization and loan from another
organization to meet some special types of needs such
as consumption, house repairing, medical treatment etc.
- Tendency to take loan from
several organizations simultaneously may arise among members
because of weak monitoring and because, sometimes Field
Workers cannot identify double membership. Group members
take this opportunity and get loan from different organizations.
Besides, some borrowers become members of different organizations,
or of different groups/samities of the same organization
simultaneously to create an "associate fund"
which may be used for lending to others.
(b)
At Managerial Level of MFIs :
1. Unplanned
expansion of loan program :
- Formation of incompatible/inconsistent
number of groups compared with the availability of loan
fund.
- Expansion of loan program
under the pressure of the members of Executive Committee
or according to the will/intention of donor organizations
without conducting any feasibility survey.
- Tendency to mobilize increased
volume of savings to finance credit program.
- Fixing up targets on behalf
of the organization :
- Some organizations fix
up targets for the officers/employees to organise a
specific number of members and to disburse a specific
amount of loan. To fulfil the target the officers/employees
disburse loans to members without assessing their quality
or without considering whether they have taken loan
from another organization.
- All organizations want
to keep their loan programs concentrated in a specific
geographical area because of infrastructural convenience.
The members avail themselves of this opportunity. Besides,
organizations having no logistic support do not want
to expand their programs to a remote area.
Objectives
and Rationale Behind Avoiding Overlapping Problem :
Now a days
overlapping is a great problem in microcredit program. Because
of this problem all organizations, particularly small ones,
are failing to achieve the desired success. Overlapping is
having negative impact on loan recovery rate and sustainability.
As one member takes two loans from two sources, there is a
risk that the second loan is used to repay the first one creating
an accumulated volume of hidden bad debt in the microcredit
sector. Further, in a situation where supply of microcredit
fund is limited, if some borrowers receive loans from more
than one organization simultaneously, other poor people will
be deprived of microcredit.
PKSF, as
an apex financing organization, is concerned about overlapping
problem. All small organizations should avoid this problem
for their own interest through discussion among themselves.
PKSF wants the members of a particular NGO not to take loans
from more than one organization at a time. Every organization
must realise the consequences of overlapping and work sincerely
to solve it. The steps to solve the problems of overlapping
may be divided into two categories:
(a) those removing the existing
overlapping problems; and
(b) those helping to avoid the
future overlapping problems.
(a)
Steps to solve the existing overlapping
problems :
- A list of the groups/samities
(including members names, full addresses and admission
dates) in a particular village of a particular organization
may be kept by each and every organizations working in
the village.
- The list of the new borrowers
of each loan providing organizations working in the same
area may be exchanged among the organizations every month.
- A "Forum" of the
organizations working in a thana should be established
and their Directors/ Branch Managers should sit together
and discuss the overlapping problem and its solution every
two months.
- A list of the members who
have taken loans from different organizations and deposited
savings with different organizations may be made and their
ultimate destination (i.e. ultimately in which organization
they want to stay) may be determined through discussion
with such members. Once a members/ borrowers
chosen organization has been determined, he should pay
all his dues to other organizations.
- The Field Workers/Organisers
of all organizations working in the same area may visit
each others group to identify whether a member or another
person of his family is taking loan from more than one
organization simultaneously. If necessary, weekly meetings
of groups/samities of different organizations working
in the same village or area may be held on the same day
at the same time. If this is done, overlapping problem
would be easily identified and solved.
- A special seal may be used
in the passbooks of members who have taken loans from
more than one organization so that they can be easily
identified.
- The list of the members
who have taken loans from different organizations should
be collected by the Field Workers/Organisers of each organizations.
The Field workers/Organisers should remind the borrowers
to repay the loan of the other organizations along with
the loan of their own organization. Step 4
mentioned above may be followed after repayment is completed.
(b)
How to avoid future overlapping :
Steps 1 to
5 of para (a) above should be implemented along with the
following measures to avoid future overlapping:
- If an organization organises
members in an area and keeps them waiting for loan and
then if another organization comes to that area to organise
members, the second organization must consult with the
first organization and also with its members.
- The time length for which
organised members are kept awaiting for loan should be
uniform for all organizations. That is, it should not
be such that an organization would give loan after two
weeks, another organization after 12 weeks, another after
18 weeks, etc.
- The list of the newly organised
members (including their names, full addresses, admission
dates etc.) of an organization should be sent to other
organization(s) within one day, so that they do not enlist
them as their members when they organise groups.
- Family should be the basis
of selecting new members. That is, if a person of a family
is a member of an organization, then other organizations
should not select anyone of that family as a member.
- If any member starts savings
with an organization and if it is found that he/she has
taken loan from another organization, then the savings
of that member should be returned and his/her membership
should be cancelled forthwith.
- If necessary, the relevant
officers of all organizations implementing microcredit
operations should discuss the issue of overlapping in
the monthly discussion meeting of their thana-based local
forum. If any problem cannot be resolved in that meeting,
then it must be referred to higher authorities of their
organizations. If higher authorities also fail to resolve
the problem, then it must be informed to PKSF in black
and white.
Capacity
Building Issues for Micro Finance Institutions and the Role
of Palli Karma-Sahayak
Foundation
- Md.
Shaikhul Islam
Introduction
:
Inspired
by the initial success of microcredit program, the NGOs of
Bangladesh have been implementing the program with a view
to alleviating poverty through the creation of employment
opportunities. Their efforts have produced reasonable success.
As a result, the NGOs have drawn special attention of development
practitioners as well as policy makers and interest groups
at home and abroad. These NGOs are now being treated as Micro
Finance Institutions (MFIs). There is a definitional difference
between an NGO and an MFI. The major difference lies in the
context of fixing up the main focus of organizational strategies
that the organizations have adopted to reach their objectives.
The purpose of this article is to point out some issues that
the MFIs need to consider seriously to make their programs
sustainable and to identify the role of PKSF in this regard.
NGOs
and MFIs: Micro Financing Perspective :
The term
"MFI" was not as familiar few years back as it is
today. The evolution and growth of MFIs is deeply related
with the emergence of NGOs. The NGOs have been implementing
different donor driven development programs and projects since
the independence of Bangladesh. However, since mid- eighties
a remarkable transition in the program objectives of the NGOs
has been clearly visible. While relief, rehabilitation and
awareness building were the major objectives of the NGOs before
mid-eighties, poverty alleviation through the provision of
microcredit has become the central program objective of all
NGOs today. The progressive decline in the availability of
soft grant money from the donor community has much to do with
this shift in program objectives.
Today the
"not for profit" organizations are involved basically
in financial activities. These organizations or MFIs, as they
are rightly called, provide different financial services to
their clients, the targeted landless and assetless people.
The financial products generally include microcredit, and
micro-savings. In order that the MFIs can operate successfully
and become sustainable, they need to consider some capacity
building issues.
Capacity
Building Issues :
The major
capacity building issues that the MFIs need to consider for
their viability and sustainability may be enumerated as follows
:
1.
Good governance
2.
Strategic planning
3.
Planned expansion of micro finance program
4.
Financial and economic viability
5.
Strategic human resource management
6. Budgetary
practice
7.
Financial management
8.
Accounting Information System (AIS)
9.
Management Information System (MIS)
10.
Monitoring and evaluation
11.
Internal audit
12.
Social acceptance
13.
Institutional sustainability
Good
Governance :
Good governance
is an area where the MFIs should give serious attention. The
highest level of authority of an MFI is its General Body.
The next level is the Executive Committee, which is basically
responsible for policy direction of MFIs. The wisdom, enlightenment,
commitment and integrity of the members of both general and
executive bodies are extremely important for the goodwill,
sustenance and growth of MFIs. Visionary direction from the
committee members would be critically helpful for MFIs to
reach their objectives.
Strategic
Planning :
Strategic
planning is the plinth of an MFI. An MFI is set up for providing
financial services to its clients. MFIs are in need to have
strategic plans covering three to five years for their future
directions, courses of actions, growth and sustainability.
All MFIs do not have unique features. They vary from one another
in terms of size, location, management style etc. So, there
can be no unique format for strategic planing for all MFIs.
Generally, MFIs should aim at achieving the following objectives
from strategic planing :
a.
To clarify the vision, mission, objectives, and strategies
of MFIs so that the staff has clear sense of direction.
b. To plan
for long term sustainability and growth.
c. To analyse
strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threat factors.
d. To find
out early warning system-appropriate proactive strategies
to encounter risks and face challenges.
e. To improve
problem solving skills.
f. To
mobilise resources etc.
Planned
Expansion
:
Unplanned
expansion, either vertical or horizontal, is a great problem
that MFIs are facing frequently. Unplanned expansion is not
congenial as well as desirable in terms of fund management,
cost effectiveness, financial, economical and programmatic
sustainability and above all for a dynamic and efficient management.
MFIs should study the feasibility of expansion before taking
any decisions to maximise their outreach. The expansion policy
of an MFI has to be considered in accordance with the strategic
planning of the MFI.
Financial
and Economic Viability :
Financial
and economic viability is very important for MFIs for their
future sustainability and growth. Financial viability is achieved
if MFIs can meet their operational expenditures from their
earnings. Moreover, if sufficient surpluses can be created
after meeting operating expenses MFIs can become economically
viable.
Strategic
Human Resource Management
:
Strategic
human resource management is another area where MFIs should
give emphasis. MFIs should formulate an appropriate human
resource development policy. MFIs should recruit dynamic and
sincere field workers, accountants, mid and top level managers.
Moreover, MFIs need to appraise staff performance on a regular
basis and provide incentive based compensation package to
the deserving staff. To accomplish the responsibilities of
such an important area properly, it would be prudent for each
MFIs to establish a human resource department.
Budgetary
Practice :
Budgetary
practice is essential for MFIs. MFIs should prepare a budget,
which will have two main heads. One is programmatic and the
other is the revenue expenditure. In the beginning of a financial
year, programmatic and revenue expenditure budget should be
completed. Major heads of programmatic budget is the expected
availability of funds, expected monthly expenditures in accordance
with the expected service charge earnings. At the end of a
financial year MFIs need to calculate budget variance in comparison
with the actual one. The thumb rule in this regard is that
MFIs have to be careful in budget variance relating to expenditures.
However, it will be an advantage for MFIs if they have other
sources of income, which can reduce the pressure on service
charge.
Financial
Management :
Financial
management is extremely important for MFIs. The efficiency
with which an MFI manages its capital, liabilities and assets
determine overall financial performance of that MFI. In this
regard MFIs can make use of different financial ratios for
taking appropriate decisions.
Accounting
Information System (AIS)
:
A sound,
transparent, standard and acceptable Accounting Information
System (AIS) has two fold implication. First, any financial
transactions must be conducted, registered and supervised
through a chain of systems that will ensure a reasonable degree
of control, and second, financial statements should be presented
to management in a way that helps them to take necessary steps
for operational purposes.
Management
Information System (MIS)
:
Existence
of an efficient Management Information system (MIS) is imperative
for MFIs. MFIs must be able to manage information without
any distortion. Distorted information and inefficient use
of information is responsible for management problems which
hinder financial and operational efficiency.
Monitoring
and Evaluation :
Monitoring
and evaluation of microfinancing program is another area where
MFIs would have to give priority. Monitoring system of an
MFI should consist of monitoring of group activities, financial
transactions, staff activities, income and cost effectiveness,
utilisation of funds, institutional goals and strategic objectives
etc. In this regard, MFIs can create a monitoring map to indicate
who is responsible for which outputs. On the other hand, for
evaluation, an MFI can study the impact of its program on
beneficiaries. It can also evaluate the operational efficiency
of the organization to run program smoothly. Moreover, continuous
monitoring, supervision and evaluation can detect loopholes
of programs and suggest curative measures. In this regard
MFIs can open a separate monitoring and evaluation department.
Internal
Audit :
Internal
audit is also extremely important for MFIs. It is the responsibility
of internal auditors to find out loopholes of financial management
of MFIs. It is a check and balance system. It would be wise
for an MFI to create an internal audit cell that will be directly
accountable to the Chief Executive Officer (CEO).
Social
Acceptance :
Social
acceptance of an MFI is also very important. An MFI would
not be institutionally sustainable unless it is also accepted
socially. Therefore, MFIs should make their objectives and
services known to people of different levels, which include
civil society, elected representatives, government agencies,
local administration, other MFIs, donors and other stakeholders.
An accountable, transparent and easily accessible MFI would
be more acceptable to the society.
Institutional
Sustainability :
The issues,
mentioned above, are to a great extent interrelated indeed.
Strategic planning of an MFI can give a clear-cut long-term
structured policy and operational guidelines to achieve institutional
sustainability. Again institutional sustainability of an MFI
depends on the financial, programmatic and economic viability;
strategic human resource management policy and its social
acceptability which would have to be monitored, supervised
and evaluated from time to time. And all these conditions
can be met if good governance can be ensured.
Role
of PKSF :
There is
a partnership relationship between PKSF and those MFIs who
are the partner organizations (POs) of PKSF. All MFIs of Bangladesh
are not POs of PKSF.
Palli Karma-Sahayak
Foundation (PKSF)- an apex financing institution has been
set up by the Government of Bangladesh in 1990 as a "not
for profit" organization. The overall objective of PKSF
is to alleviate poverty. To reach its objectives, PKSF is
implementing microcredit program targeting the landless and
assetless.
The modus
operandi of PKSF is quite unique and exceptional indeed. It
does not implement micro credit program directly at the field
level. It gets the program implemented through its POs which
are MFIs. PKSF provides fund to its POs as loan, the POs disburse
the money to their clients - the target people. PKSF encourages
its POs to follow the best delivery system.
In order
to maintain the quality of micro finance program, PKSF assesses
the needs of its POs in all respects, and it has been perceived
by PKSF that MFIs not only require funds, but they also need
a comprehensive package of institutional development (ID)
support and services to enhance their capacity for their future
sustainability. In this regard, PKSF has been continuously
providing technical assistance to its POs to formulate their
strategic plans, short-term plans, action plans and improve
MIS and AIS. Moreover, as a part of human resource development
program, PKSF also imparts training to staff of different
levels of its POs. It also provides its POs interest free
loan to buy computers and motorcycles and bicycles. PKSF will
also provide its POs with the necessary softwares for computerisation
of their MIS system.
Apart form
providing technical assistance to the POs PKSF also monitors
and supervises the POs on a regular basis to find out whether
they are on the right track or not. Moreover, PKSF also gives
importance to the good governance of its POs.
List
of literature consulted:
1.
Paranjpe, Vivek. 1997. Strategic Human Resource Planning.
APL, New Delhi, India.
2.
Asian Development Bank (ADB).
1992. "An Assessment of the Role and Impact of NGOs in
Bangladesh". Manilla:ADB.
3.
Bangladesh Institute of Development Studies and the World
Bank. 1995. Study on Rural Credit for the Poor. Dhaka: BIDS.
4.
Brown L. David & David C. Korten. 1989. The Role of Voluntary
Organizations in Development. Boston: Institute of Development
Research.
5.
Farrington John, Anthony Bebbington, Kate Wellard and
Dacid J. Lewis (eds.) 1993. Reluctant Partner: Non-Government
organizations, the State
and Sustainable Development. London:Routeledge.
6.
Valadez Joseph, Bamberger,
Michael 1994. Monitoring and Evaluating Social Programs in
Development Countries: A Handbook
for Policymakers,
Managers and Researchers. New York: The Economic Development
Institute (EDI). USA.
7.
Association of Development Agencies in Bangladesh (ADAB).
1994. Grassroots: An Alternative Development Journal (Quarterly,
Vol.3, and Issue-XII,
April-June)
8.
Christian Commission for Development in Bangladesh (CCDB).
1993. Peoples Participatory Planning Process in CCDB: Spadework.
9.
Palli Karma- Sahayak Foundation (PKSF), Annual Report. 1992-1996.
10.
Inter American Development Bank (IADB). 1994. Technical
guide for the Analysis of Micro Enterprise Finance Institutions.
11.
Shahidur R. Khandakar, Khan Zahed, Khalily Baqui. 1995. Sustainability
of a Government Targeted Credit Program: Evidence from
Bangladesh. (World Bank Discussion
Papers, Vol. 316), Washington D.C, USA.
Murshada
Faces the Flood of 1998
-
Md. Ziauddin Iqbal
"Uddipan"
a partner organization of PKSF has been implementing its program
in Daudkandi thana of Comilla district to improve socio-economic
conditions of the rural poor. The working area of this organization
spreads over 48 villages of 7 unions under the Thana.
Daudkandi
thana, a basin of the rivers Meghna-Dhonagoda, is highly flood
prone. It is about 43 kilometers away from Dhaka city. The
thana has a total population of above 5 lac. There are 5 colleges,
11 high schools and a good number of primary schools in this
area. Most people of the area are engaged in agriculture,
fishing, rickshaw pulling, small trading and services. The
road communication to the area from Dhaka city is good. Most
roads connecting the thana with other towns are paved, but
in the villages the roads are unpaved and temporary in nature.
During the rainy season the lowland and the village roads
go under 5/6 feet water and so boats become the only means
of transportation of the people. During the devastating flood
of 1998 this area remained submerged under water for about
2 months.
Doghar
is one of the villages of West Mohammadpur union of Daudkandi
thana. Murshada Begum lives in this village. She is a member
of Maddhamoloya Sramajibi Gram Sangstha supported by Uddipan.
Murshada has a medium sized CI sheet roofed-house. I talked
to Murshada sitting on a bed in her house. I found the house
quite neat and clean. As she started unfolding the story of
her life to me her husband joined her and helped her. Murshada
is 40, but she looks older than her age. She could not study
beyond primary level.
Sahidullah,
the husband of Murshada is 48 years old and he passed S.S.C.
examination. The principal occupation of Sahidullah is business
and agriculture is his part time occupation. Before getting
access to microcredit facility of NGO Murshada had a family
of 7 members-herself, her husband and 4 sons and one daughter.
The eldest son Mizan was then 15 and read in class VIII. The
second son Alamgir was 10 and read in class III. The third
child Asma, the only daughter was 8 and read in class I, the
third son Jasim was only 5 and the youngest son Yousuf was
a child of 1 year old. At that time Murshada's husband owned
5 decimals of homestead land, 15 decimals of pond land and
around 100 decimals of cultivable land. They had an ox, 3
goats and poultry birds numbering 23. The other assets owned
by the family included 3 rickshaws, one radio, one bicycle,
one tubewell donated by a government agency, a bed and a small
grocery. The family had a two-room house with CI sheet roof
and jute stick wall. They did not have sanitary latrine and
the familys source of drinking water was tubewell. Murshada
received a loan of Tk.1000 for the first time in 1992 from
Uddipon, for the purpose of agricultural activity.
There
was a notable improvement in the socio-economic conditions
of Murshadas family during the period between her joining
the NGO and the onset of the devastating flood of 1998. A
significant part of this improvement can be attributed to
microcredit. Saiful, the youngest son of Murshada was born.
Mizan and Alamgir did not continued their study after class
VIII. Now both of them are working as taxi drivers and they
are yet to get married. Asma's education ended after class
V. She is 15 now and her parents are trying for her marriage.
From his childhood Jasim was never interested in school, so
he is illiterate and now engaged in agriculture. The remaining
two little sons of Murshada, Yousuf and Saiful, read in class
III and I respectively at present. Murshada's family was able
to increase the size of their homestead land from 5 decimals
to 15 decimals. The family also built a three room CI sheet
house at a cost of Tk. 90,000. They sold the ox and bought
two cows which had given birth to two calves. Moreover, two
goats and a good number of poultry birds also were added to
the familys livestock property. The total value of this
livestock property was Tk. 22,000 approximately. The position
of the familys other assets was as follows:
| Rickshaw |
3 in number
|
|
Bed |
1 in number
|
| Radio |
4 "
|
|
Almirah |
2 "
|
| Cassette
Player |
1 "
|
|
Show
Case |
1 "
|
| Bicycle |
1 "
|
|
Table
& Chair |
5 "
|
| Clock |
3 "
|
|
Shop(
Rented) |
2 "
|
| Bed
stead |
2 "
|
|
Gold |
1 Bhori
|
All
these assets above had a value of about Tk. 70,000. The family
of Murshada used sanitary latrine and tubewell for drinking
water. The hard time of financial crisis of the family was
reduced from three months to one month - the month of November.
Murshada
Begum received loan six times from Uddipan amounting to Tk.
22,000 in all and utilized the money for undertaking different
income generating activities such as agriculture, small trade,
calf fattening etc. Her loan outstanding to Uddipan was Tk.
1400. In addition, she also received loan to the amount of
Tk. 8000 from Grameen Bank and purchased a piece of land with
the amount. She had savings amounting to Tk. 4793 with Uddipan
before the flood commenced. The other members of the family
also had savings. This was the pre-flood condition of Murshadas
family.
The devastating
flood that hit Daudkandi thana in 1998 lasted for about 60
days. Since Murshada's family did not have experiences of
facing such flood before, they could not take any measures
to cope with the flood. The crop fields and the house yard
went under water first and later on the floodwater entered
into the house and the floor of the house went under 2/3 feet
water and remained underwater for 1 month. However Murshada's
family did not leave the house for safe shelter. They stayed
in the house lifting the bed up with bricks. During the flood
nobody of her family died of illness. Only Saiful and Jasim
suffered from diarrhoea and fever. The flood caused serious
damage to the property of Murshada
's family. The extent of
damages was as follows:
| Item |
Loss
in quantity |
Loss
in Taka |
| Paddy |
1000 Kg
|
7,500
|
| Vegetables |
80 Kg
|
800
|
| Plants |
14 in no.
|
5,400
|
| Shop |
01 in no.
|
8,000
|
| Calves |
02 in no.
|
8,000
|
| Poultry |
12 in no.
|
1,000
|
| Quilt,
Pillow etc |
---
|
1,000
|
| Bamboo
made house |
01 in no.
|
1,500
|
| Other |
|
4,000
|
| |
|
37,200
|
Murshada's husband
and her sons were not able to continue their regular income
earning activities and were jobless for 60 days. Consequently
they suffered financial loss of Tk. 6000. As the family suffered
earning, Murshada could not repay 2 installments of loan amounting
Tk.160 to Uddipan which in subsequent days was adjusted against
savings by the organization as per mutual consent. To face
the effects of flood her family undertook several strategies
and measures keeping in mind that none of them should bring
any serious disaster in her life after the flood. Thus she
avoided to take loan from moneylender. She did not also sell
or mortgage any piece of land or any precious metal. She did
not also sell any animal property or other assets. Though
she had an intention to utilize her savings with Uddipan,
but she was not allowed to do so by the organization. So,
in order to meet the financial crises she borrowed Tk.1500
from her relative. The family members, excluding the two little
children ate less food during the period. The government ran
a relief program in the area and Murshada's family received
45-Kg of wheat and 15 Kg rice. Uddipan, also provided her
family saline packets, water purification tablets, iodised
salt and medical services free of cost during the flood and
helped to clean her tubewell after the flood.
After the
flood Murshada has started taking measures to reconstruct
her life. The flood could not weaken her morale and confidence.
Her family has resumed their income generating activities
and hopes to regain whatever they lost. Murshada has received
microcredit again from Uddipan after the flood. Murshada dreams
again to free her family from the vicious cycle of poverty
and to make her children happy. She relies heaving on microcredit
to fulfil her dream.
Hasna
Survives the Flood of 1998
- Sajal
Halder
Hasna Begum,
a member of Shaplaful Mohila Samity organised by Samaj Kallayan
O Palli Unnayan Sangstha (SPUS), was severely affected during
the devastating flood of 1998. Hasna lives in the village
of "Khudra Tepra" of Ullayl union under Shivalaya
thana in the district of Manikgonj.
SPUS is
a non-government organization (NGO) working in the district
of Manikgonj. SPUS started its activities about 15 years ago
as a club with a view to helping the poor. As a Partner Organization
(PO) of PKSF, now its operational area spreads over 105 villages
of 3 thanas in the district of Manikgonj. SPUS has two offices
one head office-cum-branch office in the village Rupsha
and another liaison office-cum-branch office in the village
Tepra. Village Tepra is situated near the Aricha Ghat. Aricha
Ghat is only five kilometre from Tepra. The SPUS served 3
thanas Shivalaya, Harirampur and Ghior are situated
by the side of the river Padma. The total number of inhabitants
in three thanas is about 10 lac. There are 12 colleges, 50
high schools, and a good number of government primary schools,
some registered (but not government) primary schools and more
than 20 madrashas in this area. Most people of the area are
engaged in agriculture, fishing, hawchuring, rickshaw pulling,
small trading, service and handicrafts making.
Hasna Begum
lives in the village Khudra Tepra which is situated near Tepra
and on the southern side of Dhaka-Aricha Highway. The village
looks very beautiful. Hasna begum is known as a simple and
sincere housewife in her village. She is about 25 years old
and her husband Abdur Razzak is about 35 years old. Her family
consists of 4 members husband, herself, one son and
one daughter. The elder among the two children is Rita Akter.
She is 12 years old and reads in class six. The son, Hasan
is 10 years old and he reads in class five.
Hasna is
a member of Shaplaful Mohila Samity. I was acquainted with
Hasna when I attended her Samitys weekly meeting. Hasna
is one of those who faced flood of 1998. After the Samitys
weekly meeting was over, I reached her house coming past some
bundles of bamboo and walking by side of a big pond. The pond
belongs to Gulzar master who is a neighbour of Hasna Begum.
The pond covers an area of about 8 acres of land. While coming
to the residence of Hasna walking by the side of the pond
many men and women were seen to take bath in the pond. As
I entered into the yard of the house, I got a warm reception
from all members of Hasnas family. Hasna has a small
sized one room CI sheet-roofed and straw-fenced house. Hasnas
husband Abdur Razzak was making a shelf of cane. He gave me
a tool made of cane to sit beside him. Talking to me, both
husband and wife unfolded their story of struggle at the time
of flood, 1998. Abdur Razzak now is a craftsman specializing
in cane goods. Hasna is a housewife and helps in the works
of her husband. They engaged themselves in this occupation
only two years back. Before that Abdur Razzak was a rickshaw-puller
in the city of Dhaka. Two years back he returned to his village
where he was born. Hasna also was born in the same village.
Hasna married Abdur Razzak, the son of Md. Sahabuddin of the
same village 12 years ago. They were passing the golden days
of their life, Hasna said. But the flood of 1998 destroyed
the dream of their life. After the flood it was very difficult
to run their family. Razzak decided to go to Dhaka and pull
rickshaw again, if any other better alternative was not available
there. To begin with he got no other job and so started pulling
a rented rickshaw. But the income was not sufficient to meet
his own and his familys need. So he kept on trying to
get a better job and finally he got one. He started working
as a salesman in a shop of cane handicrafts in Dhaka and learnt
the trade of making cane-goods. He soon returned to his village
and started making cane handicrafts himself. Hasna who is
a member of SPUS borrowed Tk. 3,000 from SPUS and helped him
to start a cane handicraft making business. The family started
earning Tk. 3500 per month. But before receiving microcredit
facility provided by SPUS, they lived from hand to mouth.
They had no cultivable land. Hasnas husband Abdur Razzak
owned only 6 decimals of homestead land and only 3 decimals
of pond land. They had a rickshaw which was bought with Tk.
2300. The rickshaw was sold for Tk. 2000 which was invested
in their business. They had a wall-clock and a radio that
valued Tk. 500/- approximately. They had only one wooden bed
in the house valuing Tk. 700/- only. Hasnas only gold
ornament was her nose pin which was bought with Tk. 200 by
her husband. They had a one room CI sheet-roof and straw-fenced
house valuing Tk. 2000 only and had no sanitary latrine and
tube-well. But Hasna was not frustrated, she was determined
to improve her life. She dreamt in her broken house that her
son and daughter would go to school and would be educated.
They would get job and help them in their old age. But their
financial crisis was an obstacle to their dream. She was unable
to continue her sons study in the school. Just at this
crisis moment, Hasna was advised by her neighbours to receive
a loan from an NGO and to start a business. The hard time
indicating financial crisis of her family lasted, more or
less, all the months of the year. Hasna decided to get her
husband back to the village, to start handicraft business.
She became a member of a samity of SPUS and got a loan of
Tk. 3000 from SPUS on 25.07.97 and started the business.
They pursued
their business seriously and worked hard, even at night. Their
sales went up. They increased their production of goods in
large quantity. Razzak started to supply some goods to the
shop of his x-employer in Dhaka. Hasna repaid the first loan
and they needed more capital. So she took another loan of
Tk. 5000 from SPUS on 27.06.98. Their business was expanding
and took a good shape. Profit was satisfactory and they were
almost able to overcome their financial crisis of the past-days.
Hasan and Rita got new dresses and started to go to school
regularly. Before flood of 1998, the daughter, Rita Akter
was eleven and read in class V. The son Hasan was nine years
old and read in class four. Both of them did well in the examination.
The profit gained from the business was spent for the purpose
of their study. The family bought a goat, and by taking proper
care of it, they increased it to five. They also bought two
hens and increased it to seventeen. They bought a second hand
black and white TV at a price of Tk. 4000. They bought wrist
watches for their son and daughter at a price of Tk. 400,
two stools at a price of Tk. 1200, a bed at price of Tk. 1300
and a table for TV at Tk. 600. However, they did not reconstruct
or made any new house for their living. The reason is that
one of Razzaks brothers lives in Dhaka and he is financially
solvent. His village house is well constructed and remained
unused. Razzaks family stayed in that house and took
care of the house. They made some ornaments, such as, an ear-ring,
a nose-pin and two rings of gold that valued approximately
Tk. 3000/-. They had also crockery for their regular use.
But as they did not use their own house, they did not maintain
the house properly. As a result the house was partially destroyed.
Also they did not build any sanitary latrine or own any tubewell.
It proves that they were not conscious about health education.
Before
the flood of 1998, Hasna had taken loan two times from SPUS
amounting to Tk. 9000 of which first loan of Tk. 3000 was
fully paid and the second loan of Tk. 6000 was partially paid.
Hasnas loan outstanding was then Tk. 4800. At the same
time she deposited savings amounting to Tk 145. Before receiving
microcredit facility, Hasnas financial crisis remained
round the year. But after starting their business by taking
the loan from NGO, their financial crisis period was reduced
to 3 months of the year, Ashar, Sraban and Vadhra.
Suddenly
Hasna became emotional. She told me that they were able to
overcome the crisis of bad days but it was difficult for them
to overcome the loss of flood. The flood of 1998 lasted for
3 months in their area. To begin with crops went under water.
They thought water would decrease soon. But unfortunately
it was the opposite. Flood water started rising and the house
yard went under water. They were frightened. They didnt
become hopeless because they had the experience of facing
the flood of 1988. But beyond all past experiences, the flood
water entered into the house of Hasna. They tried first to
stay in the house raising the bed. But it was not enough,
flood water went on rising. Finally, they had to leave their
own house and took shelter in Gulzar Masters house which
was a two storied-building and situated about 150 yards away
from their house. Many people of their village took shelter
in that house and all lived together for about a month. The
flood damaged a lot of vegetables and different types of trees
mainly fruit and bamboo trees. Hasna lost vegetables of about
Tk. 1000, fine Jackfruit-trees of Tk 7500/- and 10 bamboo
trees of about Tk. 2000/-. Their house was fully damaged which
had a value of Tk. 2000. Different furniture such as table,
and bed and crockery, were partially damaged which had a value
of approximately Tk. 1000. In addition 15 hens valuing Tk.
800 also died. Moreover they could not work three months at
the time of flood for which they lost Tk. 12000.
Basically
they had no preparation to face the flood although they had
experience of 1988 flood. When the flood started, they had
a hard cash of Tk. 7000/- which was spent during the time
of the flood. But that was not enough. Hasna took a loan Tk.
1000 from an uncle and also purchased grocery on credit for
Tk. 500 from a nearby shop. A considerable amount of their
hard cash was spent for medical treatment of Hasan and Razzak
who suffered from diarrhoea and fever. Her daughter Rita Akter
did not suffer from any disease and she was safe.
During
the 3 months of flood, Hasna could not pay the weekly loan
installment of one month, i.e. 4 weeks. SUPS also did not
put any pressure to repay the loan. At the end of the flood,
she paid the 4 overdue installments in the month of November.
In the meantime her husband Abdur Razzak contacted his ex-employee
in Dhaka and took a loan of Tk. 2000 in order to resume his
business again. He did not pay the loan in cash but in kind
supplying handicrafts produced by him within 3 months. His
ex-employer took no interest directly but when he received
the goods, he paid at a lower rate. Razzak told that he lost
Tk. 600 by supplying goods to him and the effective rate of
interest was more than 100%. Hasna needed capital to run the
business. She got a new loan of Tk. 8000. She paid the loans
which were taken at the time of flood from his uncle and the
shopkeeper. It is mentionable that at the time of flood they
received very little support from NGOs and local government.
She received only 4 kg of rice, 1 kg of dal from Proshika,
and 15 kg of rice, 1 litre of oil, 1 kg of salt and 4 kg of
dal from Prizom Bangladesh and no support from the Union Council
and her organization, SPUS. At the time of flood, she sold
two hens and a goat for Tk. 400 which was spent for meeting
daily expenses. Hasna did not receive any loan from savings
at the time of flood because she deposited only 145/- taka
as savings to the organization. She felt the importance of
savings during the flood time.
Hasna and
her husband Abdur Razzak were very much active to overcome
the loss or damage suffered during and after the flood. Soon
after the flood, they started to produce cane-goods in full
capacity. They needed money to purchase raw materials. But
there is no provision to get two loans at a time from SPUS.
Therefore she became member another NGO, Proshika and took
a loan of Tk. 7000 in February, 1999. When I asked her how
she could get a loan of Tk. 7000 from Proshika. She told that
in the year 1996, she was a member of a group of Proshika
and took a loan of Tk. 3000 which was fully paid. So proshika
knew her and her repayment behavior and gave her Tk. 7,000/-.
Hasna and
her husband Abdur Razzak have overcome the disastrous impact
of the flood with the help of microcredit and now their earning
is quite normal.
|